Both brands build some of the finest driver's cars in the world, but they reward completely different personalities behind the wheel.
The case for Ferrari
Theater. A Ferrari announces itself before you even start the engine — the styling, the badge, the sound at idle. It is the car for renters who want every head on Jumeirah Beach Road to turn.
The case for Porsche
Precision. A 911 is easier to live with day to day, more forgiving at the limit, and just as capable of embarrassing far more expensive cars on a mountain road.
Our verdict
If it's your first supercar rental and the goal is spectacle, go Ferrari. If you actually plan to drive it every day of your trip, go Porsche.